Pin it
This pecan pie has been my trusted dessert for ages and it always gets my family smiling! There's just something wonderful about that tasty mix of flaky crust and sticky filling packed with crunchy pecans. Whenever I take this pie out of the oven, my house fills up with this amazing buttery smell that reminds me of holidays at my grandma's table.
Why This Pie Stands Out
I've gotta tell you what makes this Pioneer Woman style recipe my favorite! The filling hits that sweet spot between sugary and nutty while the crust stays nice and crisp. I'm crazy about how the pecans float up to make that gorgeous top as it cooks. Even my pals who say they can't bake have nailed this simple recipe.
Ingredients You'll Want
- Unbaked Pie Crust: I stick with my go-to all butter crust because it really enhances everything.
- Chopped Pecans: Try to grab fresh ones for way better taste.
- Light Corn Syrup: This gives you that sticky goodness everyone wants.
- Brown Sugar: You can use either dark or light with great results.
- Eggs: Make sure they're not cold for easier mixing.
- Vanilla: Real vanilla extract adds that cozy flavor.
Baking It Together
- Getting Your Crust Ready
- Stretch your dough out thin to about 12 inches for your 9 inch pan. Don't rush the edges as a pretty scalloped pattern makes it extra nice.
- Mixing Up Your Filling
- Grab your bowl and stir the sugars salt corn syrup and melted butter until they look shiny. Add in those room temp eggs and vanilla until you've got a smooth silky mixture.
- Putting It All Together
- Spread those beautiful pecans across your crust. I always put a few more around the edges because they toast up so nicely! Then slowly pour that sweet mixture over all the nuts and watch them rise to the top.
- Oven Time
- Put some foil loosely on top so it doesn't get too brown too fast. Take the foil off after 30 minutes and keep baking until the middle just barely wobbles. It'll firm up more as it sits.
- Cooling Down
- I know you want to dig in but let it cool all the way! Those extra hours mean you'll get clean slices later. Sometimes I make mine the day before just to be safe.
Tricks I've Learned
After making tons of pecan pies, here's what works best. Always use pecans you've chopped yourself as they taste way better than the pre-cut ones. Don't bother toasting them first since they'll toast while baking anyway. And please wait until it's totally cool before slicing if you want those picture-perfect pieces!
Fixing Common Problems
- My filling won't set: Just stick it back in the oven for a few more minutes at a time until it firms up.
- Dark or light corn syrup: I prefer dark for holiday desserts as it gives such a rich taste!
- Keeping it fresh: Put it in the fridge once it cools completely to keep that filling just right.
Tasty Variations
- Add some chocolate: Toss in chocolate chips for something extra yummy.
- Try a splash of bourbon: It makes it feel fancy and grown-up.
- Switch the sweetener: Real maple syrup creates an amazing flavor profile.
Take It Up A Notch
Want to really impress everyone? Serve each piece slightly warm with a big scoop of vanilla ice cream on top. The way it melts down into the pie is just incredible. Add a little drizzle of caramel sauce and it becomes totally irresistible!
Getting Ahead
This pie works great for busy holidays! Bake it up to three months early, wrap it carefully and freeze it. Just let it thaw in your fridge overnight before you need it. The taste and texture stay just as good as fresh.
Old-Fashioned Goodness
There's a good reason why folks have loved this recipe forever. That perfect mix of sweet gooey filling, crunchy nuts and buttery crust just can't be topped. Whether it's for Thanksgiving, Christmas or just because you're craving something delicious, this pie always delivers.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why does it take longer to bake sometimes?
Ovens can vary, and things like the type of pie dish or ingredient temperature can affect the timing. When the middle is firm but has a slight jiggle, it's ready.
- → Do I really need foil?
Foil stops the pecans and crust from overbrowning. It keeps everything golden and prevents burning while inside the oven.
- → How do I check if it’s ready?
If the center jiggles a lot, it’s not baked enough. Keep it in the oven longer, covered with foil, until the filling stays mostly firm.
- → Why cut it into tiny pieces?
This pie is super sweet and rich. Small servings make the taste more enjoyable and allow more slices for sharing.
- → Can I prep it in advance?
Sure, since this pie sets as it cools, it's perfect to make the night before and serve the next day.
Conclusion
A Southern favorite pie loaded with sweet filling and crunchy pecans. Perfect for festivities, it’s easy to bake and enjoy with loved ones.