Pin it
Experience classic cookies and cream ice cream reimagined with this protein-rich homemade version. Using the Ninja Creami, this recipe delivers the perfect balance of smooth, creamy texture and chocolate cookie pieces while keeping sugar content in check.
After extensive testing to create a healthier frozen dessert, this recipe emerged as the perfect solution. The game-changing discovery was using ultra-filtered milk to boost protein while maintaining the smooth, creamy consistency ice cream demands.
Key Ingredients
- Ultra-filtered milk: Provides protein and creamy base
- Heavy cream: Creates essential rich texture
- Thin chocolate sandwich cookies: Perfect crunch factor
- Cookie pudding powder: Enhances authentic flavor
- Additional sweetener: Optional, to taste
- Additional mix-ins: Customize as desired
Preparation Method
- Step 1:
- Mix Base: Combine milk and cream with precise measurements. Incorporate pudding mix slowly. Check sweetness level. Mix until completely smooth.
- Step 2:
- Freeze Properly: Transfer to clean Ninja pint. Seal well to prevent crystallization. Place horizontally in freezer. Freeze minimum 24 hours.
- Step 3:
- Process Ice Cream: Select lite ice cream setting. Perform two re-spins. Check texture. Add milk if needed. Mix in cookie pieces.
Pin it
Through careful testing of various dairy options, ultra-filtered milk proved ideal for achieving the perfect protein-to-creaminess ratio. This simple ingredient swap dramatically improved the final product.
Problem Solving
For crumbly texture: Add small amount of milk. Process again. Verify freezer settings. Double-check measurements. Complete full spin cycle.
Storage Guidelines
Store in Ninja container. Place deep in freezer. Thaw 10 minutes before serving. Process again if needed. Best enjoyed within 14 days.
Pin it
This protein-enriched cookies and cream recipe delivers classic ice cream satisfaction while aligning with modern nutrition goals. The result is a perfectly balanced frozen treat that proves healthy adjustments can enhance rather than compromise flavor.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What makes Fairlife milk a good choice here?
- Fairlife milk has more protein than standard milk, which ramps up the nutrition in this tasty ice cream.
- → Is it okay to use regular pudding mix?
- You can use either regular or sugar-free pudding mix—it depends on what you like!
- → Why is the spinning process repeated?
- Spinning it multiple times removes ice crystals, leaving a silky, smooth texture.
- → Can this recipe work in other ice cream machines?
- This one’s designed specifically for the Ninja Creami, so other machines may not give the same results.
- → How long will this dessert stay fresh?
- For the best flavor and texture, enjoy it within two weeks of freezing.