Pin it
Heavenly Peanut Butter Frozen Yogurt Sticks
I stumbled upon these frozen yogurt sticks by accident and knew right away they were winners. There's something magical when you blend smooth peanut butter with tangy Greek yogurt and rich dark chocolate. They've become my go-to summer cooler. I always make extra batches for the freezer so we've got something cool, tasty and better-for-you when the ice cream craving hits.
Guilt-Free Delights For Hot Days
What I really love about these bars is how they knock out those dessert cravings with stuff I don't mind my family eating. The way the peanut butter mixes with Greek yogurt creates this dreamy frozen base, and that chocolate shell adds just enough decadence. My little ones think they're getting spoiled with a fancy dessert while I'm quietly happy they're enjoying something with actual nutritional value.
Your Ingredients List
- Greek Yogurt: Go for full-fat to get that super creamy result.
- Peanut Butter: Smooth works way better than chunky for this.
- Maple Syrup: Pure goodness, or honey works too.
- Vanilla Extract: A tiny bit makes a huge difference.
- Roasted Salted Peanuts: They add that perfect crunch factor.
- Chocolate: Semisweet is my pick but choose what you like.
- Coconut Oil: This helps the chocolate coat everything perfectly.
Steps To Frozen Perfection
- Prepare Yogurt Mixture:
- Mix your peanut butter, yogurt, vanilla and maple syrup until everything's nice and smooth.
- Form Mounds:
- Get your baking sheet ready with some parchment and drop spoonfuls of your mixture.
- Insert Sticks:
- Push popsicle sticks in halfway, then cover with more of your mixture to lock them in.
- Add Peanuts:
- Scatter those crunchy peanuts all over each treat before freezing them solid.
- Melt Chocolate:
- Stir your chocolate with coconut oil until it's all melted and shiny.
- Coat Bars:
- Dunk each frozen yogurt bar into the chocolate and watch it harden instantly.
Insider Tips
Don't skimp on the Greek yogurt—full-fat makes these bars incredibly smooth. Give your mixture a little taste test before freezing to make sure the sweetness is right. Sometimes I'll toss in some tiny chocolate chips or switch to almond butter for a change. They're both seriously yummy in their own way.
Storage Smarts
These treats will stay good in your freezer for about 3 months if you keep them in something airtight. I usually wrap each one by itself so they're ready to grab when the temperature soars. This trick keeps them fresh longer too, though at my house they're usually gone within a week.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What does coconut oil do in the chocolate?
It makes the chocolate smoother to dip and creates a thinner, easier-to-bite coating once frozen.
- → Is natural peanut butter okay to use?
Stick to regular creamy peanut butter. Natural kinds freeze too hard and might end up separating.
- → Why should I use Greek yogurt over regular?
It’s thicker, has more protein, and freezes better without turning icy.
- → How long can I store these?
Wrap them well, and they’ll taste great for up to a month in the freezer. Let them thaw slightly before eating.
- → Can I leave out the chopped peanuts?
Sure, but they give a satisfying crunch and balance the sweetness. Chopped almonds work too if you want a switch.