Pin it
The ultimate comfort mashup happens when spicy White Chicken Chili meets creamy Mac and Cheese in one dish. This hearty one-pot wonder brings together zesty chili spices and gooey cheese sauce, all cooked right in the same pan for maximum flavor and minimum cleanup.
During a freezing cold snap last year, I threw together my family's most-requested comfort foods into this tasty mashup. Everyone went crazy for how the pasta soaked up all those spicy flavors while swimming in that rich cheese sauce.
Key Ingredients
- Chicken Breasts: Get boneless ones for quick and easy shredding
- Elbow Macaroni: Those little curves trap sauce perfectly
- Poblano Peppers: Brings mild heat and smoky flavor
- Cream Cheese: Makes everything extra smooth and velvety
- White Cheddar: Gives that tangy bite we all love
- Pepper Jack: Brings extra kick and stretchy goodness
- Green Chilies: Adds that authentic southwestern kick
- Salsa Verde: Gives a zingy, bright flavor punch
- Fresh Cilantro: The perfect finishing touch
Step-by-Step Directions
- Base Development (15 minutes):
- Melt butter in deep, wide pot. Cook onions till soft and clear. Toss in chicken with spices. Let it brown slightly. Throw in garlic and poblanos. Cook everything together until fragrant.
- Building Flavors (12-15 minutes):
- Pour broth into pot. Cook chicken completely. Pull chicken out and shred it. Keep broth bubbling gently. Put chicken back in. Taste and add more seasoning if needed.
- Pasta Integration (10-12 minutes):
- Dump pasta straight into the broth. Add some water. Stir often so nothing sticks to the bottom. Cook till pasta gets tender. Cut cream cheese into chunks and mix in. Keep stirring until it's all melted away.
- Final Assembly (8-10 minutes):
- Stir in the salsa verde and chilies. Add the white beans. Mix in half the cheese. Sprinkle remaining cheese on top. Stick it in the oven. Bake until it's bubbling and slightly browned.
Pin it
My big aha moment happened when I tried cooking the pasta right in the seasoned broth instead of separately. The macaroni soaks up all those amazing flavors while also helping thicken up the sauce naturally.
Insider Chef Tricks
- Let cheese come to room temp before grating
- Keep some hot broth nearby to thin sauce if needed
- Cook your spices in the oil first for better flavor
- Save a bit of cheese to sprinkle on each serving
Pin it
Heat Management
- Cook pasta at a gentle bubble not a rolling boil
- Take the pot off heat before adding cream cheese
- Let it cool a few minutes after baking
- Watch carefully when melting the cheese
- Lower your oven temp if your pot heats quickly
Serving Ideas
- Squeeze of fresh lime
- Handful of chopped cilantro
- Chunks of ripe avocado
- Crunchy tortilla chips
- Dollop of cool sour cream
Prep Ahead Strategies
- Cook and shred chicken a day before
- Keep cheese in ziplock bag
- Mix spices ahead of time
- Chop toppings early
- Add splash of broth when warming leftovers
This One Pot White Chicken Chili Mac and Cheese shows what happens when you mash up two awesome comfort foods into something even more delicious. The spicy kick of chicken chili mixed with creamy, cheesy pasta creates a meal that's way more than the sum of its parts. It'll satisfy both your chili and mac cheese cravings at once, whether you're fighting off winter blues or just feeding a hungry crowd.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why use one pot for pasta?
- Cooking pasta in the same pot makes it creamier and soaks up all the flavor.
- → How can I change the heat level?
- Add or cut back on poblanos, chiles, or spicy cheese to suit your taste.
- → Why soften cream cheese first?
- Softened cream cheese mixes better into the sauce without clumping.
- → Which cheeses melt best?
- Colby, cheddar, or pepper jack are top choices for creamy results.
- → Can I prep this in advance?
- It tastes best fresh, but reheating with a little milk can bring back the creaminess.