Pin it
I always jump for joy when Christmas rolls around because I get to bake these amazing Melty Butter Cookies. They're exactly what you want in a holiday treat - pillowy soft and downright addictive. The game-changer? It's all about that cream cheese that makes them melt-in-your-mouth tender and those holiday sprinkles that bring the festive fun. They're always the first treats to vanish at any cookie exchange.
Why These Cookies Stand Out
If gooey butter cake makes you smile, these cookies will make you dance. They pack all that wonderful buttery goodness into bite-sized treats. The cream cheese works magic for that super soft texture, while festive sprinkles add that Christmas sparkle everyone loves. They come together in no time too, which is perfect when your holiday baking list is a mile long.
Your Ingredient List
- Cream Cheese: You'll need a solid block of full-fat cream cheese, not the stuff in tubs which won't work for our texture.
- Unsalted Butter: This brings that dreamy, melt-away quality we're after.
- Egg: One large egg will bind everything nicely together.
- Vanilla Extract: A bit of pure vanilla kicks up the flavor wonderfully.
- Yellow Cake Mix: This clever shortcut is why these cookies turn out so incredibly soft.
- Powdered Sugar: This creates that beautiful crackled look on top.
- Christmas Sprinkles: Choose whatever holiday colors make you happy.
Baking Instructions
- Prep Time
- Start by heating your oven to 350°F and putting parchment on your cookie sheets so nothing sticks.
- Combine Wet Ingredients
- Mix your softened cream cheese with butter, egg, and vanilla until you've got a smooth, creamy blend.
- Mix In Dry Stuff
- Add the cake mix and watch as it turns into this wonderful thick, tacky dough.
- Add Some Sparkle
- Carefully fold those pretty sprinkles in, trying not to crush them as you mix.
- Cool It Down
- Let your dough chill in the fridge for half an hour so it's easier to handle.
- Roll and Coat
- Form the dough into 1 1/2 inch balls, then roll them around in powdered sugar until covered.
- Bake Them Up
- Put them on your lined sheets with space between and bake for 10-12 minutes until just set at the edges but still soft in the middle.
- Cooling Stage
- Let them sit on the hot pan for a couple minutes before moving them to a cooling rack.
Custom Variations
There are so many ways to switch these cookies up. Maybe try white or vanilla cake mix for something different, or add a splash of lemon, almond, or peppermint flavor. Throw in some mini chocolate chips or bits of crushed candy canes too. Want them to look even more festive? A tiny drop of food coloring in the dough or rolling in colored sugar instead of powdered will make them pop at any party.
Insider Baking Tricks
Want to know how I get these gooey butter cookies just right? Always let your cream cheese and butter sit out till they're room temp - they'll mix up so much better. Don't overwork the dough when mixing or you'll lose that light texture. Sure, waiting for the dough to chill is annoying but it'll save you from sticky fingers. And keep an eye on them while baking - you want that perfect balance of set edges with gooey centers.
Storage Solutions
These treats stay wonderfully soft for up to three days when you keep them in a sealed container on your counter. Need to plan ahead? Pop them in the freezer for up to three months. Just stack them carefully in a freezer-safe container and let them thaw naturally when you're ready to enjoy. They'll taste just as good as they did on baking day.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why chill the dough first?
It helps the dough get firm, making it easier to roll into balls and stopping the cookies from spreading too much in the oven.
- → Are these freezer-friendly?
Totally. Store them in a sealed bag or container for up to 3 months. Just defrost at room temperature when ready to eat.
- → Why does full-fat cream cheese work best?
It gives the cookies velvety richness and keeps that gooey texture intact. Using low-fat might change the result.
- → Can I use other cake mix flavors?
Absolutely! While yellow cake mix is a classic pick, swap it out for vanilla or chocolate if you feel like a twist.
- → How do I tell if they're baked enough?
They're good to go once the edges look firm, but the centers stay a bit soft—this takes about 10-12 minutes. They'll keep setting as they cool down.