Pin it
I've mastered this home-cooked lobster tail that brings fancy restaurant quality straight to your table. The juicy meat gets soaked in a flavorful garlic herb butter mixture and broiled till it's golden—making an amazing special dinner. And guess what? You'll have it ready in less than 20 minutes but everyone will think you spent all day cooking.
Why This Dish Stands Out
You don't need to pay those crazy restaurant prices when you can whip up stunning lobster tails at home. The magic happens when that garlic herb butter hits the broiler, giving you perfectly juicy meat every single time. They're my go-to for romantic evenings or whenever I want to wow my family with something truly special.
Essential Lobster Tail Components
- Lobster Tails: Cold water varieties give you the most flavorful meat.
- Butter: Get unsalted and melt it down for our rich topping.
- Garlic Cloves: Nothing beats the smell of freshly minced garlic.
- Salt and Pepper: Just a touch enhances the natural flavors.
- Paprika: Adds a gorgeous color and light smokiness.
- Thyme and Rosemary: These fresh herbs take everything up a notch.
- Parsley: Adds that perfect finishing touch of green.
Lobster Tail Cooking Method
- Step 1 - Butterfly the Lobster Tails
- Turn your broiler on high. Take kitchen shears and cut down the middle of each shell, then carefully pull that gorgeous meat up and lay it over the shell. Add your seasonings.
- Step 2 - Make the Garlic Herb Butter
- Combine your melted butter with all those yummy garlic herbs and paprika, then paint it generously over the meat.
- Step 3 - Broil the Lobster
- Place them under the broiler roughly 4-5 inches from the heat source. They'll cook to perfection in about 8-10 minutes.
- Step 4 - Serve Immediately
- Sprinkle with fresh parsley and bring to the table with extra melted butter and some lemon wedges for a truly amazing meal.
Insider Cooking Secrets
Splurge on cold water lobster tails, they're totally worth the extra cost. Be patient when you're butterflying them—it makes them look so much fancier. I figure about 1 minute cooking time per ounce and always check with a thermometer for that ideal 145°F. When I've got company coming, I get the tails prepped early so they're all set to go under the broiler.
Cooking Duration Guidelines
Tiny tails usually need about 7-8 minutes, average ones take around 8-10, and those jumbo beauties need 10-12 minutes. For bigger tails, I lower the oven rack a bit so they don't burn—they need a bit more TLC.
Alternative Cooking Techniques
Though broiling is what I like best, you can also stick them in a 375°F oven for roughly 15 minutes, throw them on the grill for a smoky twist, or even simmer them slowly in butter for the ultimate luxury. Each way brings something unique to these gorgeous tails.
Pin it
Complete Your Dinner
We typically pair these with buttery string beans, crispy parmesan cauliflower, or smooth mashed potatoes. And don't forget to make some Cheddar Bay Biscuits for that true steakhouse feel. Finish with something indulgent like Death by Chocolate Cheesecake for a truly unforgettable meal.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What’s the best way to butterfly a lobster tail?
- Snip through the top shell using kitchen scissors, then gently lift the meat while keeping the base intact.
- → When is a lobster tail cooked through?
- The meat will look solid white and slightly golden on top after 8–10 minutes under the broiler.
- → Can I prep these ahead of time?
- It’s best to cook lobster fresh, but you can prep the garlic herb butter in advance.
- → What pairs nicely with lobster tails?
- Add some greens or a side of lemon butter, asparagus, or a fresh salad for a balanced meal.
- → Why go with broiling instead of baking?
- Broiling gives you direct heat for a crisp, golden top while leaving the meat tender.