Pin it
Whip up this festive Sugar Cookie Cheesecake that screams holiday cheer! It combines a crispy sugar cookie base, velvety cheesecake center studded with bite-sized cookie dough chunks, and a silky white chocolate finish. It's your go-to dessert when you want something that wows guests without complicated techniques.
Benefits of Trying
Can't decide between sugar cookies or cheesecake? This treat gives you both at once. It's a total crowd-pleaser at gatherings - everyone will bug you for the instructions. Grab quality sugar if you can. The tiny cookie dough bits hidden throughout make this way more exciting than standard cheesecake.
Required Ingredients
- Flour: All-purpose works perfectly
- Baking Soda: Small amount needed
- Salt: Just a dash
- Butter: Unsalted, plenty of it
- Sugar: Granulated variety
- Vanilla: Pure extract preferred
- Eggs: Large size
- Sprinkles: Holiday-themed colors
- Cream Cheese: Four packages
- Sour Cream: Creates creaminess
- Heavy Cream: For batter and topping
- White Chocolate: For the finishing layer
- 9-inch Pan: Must be springform type
Preparation Steps
- Prep work:
- Preheat to 350°. Coat springform pan with spray. Line the bottom with parchment.
- Cookie layer first:
- Combine flour, baking soda, salt separately. In another container, cream butter with sugar until light. Add vanilla and eggs. Gradually mix in dry ingredients. Spread into pan and flatten. Bake until golden brown, about 25 minutes.
- Create cookie bits:
- Prepare another batch of dough using flour, salt, butter, sugar, vanilla and milk. Form into mini balls. Set in freezer until firm.
- Prepare filling:
- Lower oven to 325°. Beat cream cheese with sugar until completely smooth. Add sour cream, cream, and vanilla. Slowly incorporate eggs. Fold frozen dough balls in carefully.
- Assemble dessert:
- Pour mixture over cooled cookie crust. Place pan inside larger one filled with hot water. Bake approximately 90 minutes until center slightly wobbles.
- Cooling process:
- Leave oven door ajar for 30 minutes. Remove and cool further. Refrigerate overnight.
- Decorate top:
- Warm cream and pour over white chocolate. Mix until blended. Spread across chilled cake. Decorate with remaining dough balls and sprinkles.
Pin it
Sugar Selection Tips
Quality sugar really makes a difference. Go for premium brands when possible. Standard granulated works just fine too. Whatever type you pick, make sure you cream it thoroughly with the butter for the best flavor outcome.
Cookie Ball Tips
Keep your dough balls super small, about penny-sized. Get the little ones to help roll them. They need to be completely frozen or they'll disappear in the batter. Skip raw dough tasting if that concerns you. Some folks just buy pre-made cookie dough as a shortcut.
Mastering Your Cheesecake
Always start with room temperature cream cheese to avoid lumps. Don't overmix after adding eggs or you'll get cracks. The water bath keeps everything moist. Cooling with the door open prevents sudden temperature changes. It's a slow process but totally worth your patience.
Perfecting The Topping
Cut your chocolate into tiny pieces for smooth melting. Keep the cream just warm, not boiling, or your chocolate will seize up. Work quickly when spreading before it sets. Some people enjoy adding decorative patterns. Let it firm up completely in the fridge before slicing.
Storage Advice
It'll stay good in your fridge for 5 days. Keep it tightly wrapped to maintain moisture. Use a warm knife for clean cuts, wiping between slices. Want to save it longer? Wrap individual pieces well for freezing up to a month. Let them thaw slightly before serving.
Customization Ideas
Switch up sprinkle colors for different celebrations. Some people toss chocolate chips into the filling. Need something fancier? Add dollops of whipped cream before serving. Try making smaller versions in a muffin tin, just reduce the baking time.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I prep this early?
Definitely! It actually gets better with time. Make it the day before so the flavors blend well. The texture also improves after chilling. Thinking ahead pays off - less stress on serving day. Just wrap it tightly, so it doesn’t take on fridge smells. Many folks claim it’s amazing after two or three days. Plan ahead for dessert magic!
- → No sour cream? Substitutes?
Greek yogurt is perfect! Use the same amount as sour cream for a slightly tangier taste but still rich and creamy. Plain yogurt works too—just strain it if it's watery. Cream cheese with a splash of milk also works, or for extra richness, go with heavy cream. Room temperature is key when mixing; cold ingredients cause lumps. Avoid regular yogurt—it’s too thin.
- → How to make it set properly?
A water bath is the trick! Place a foil-wrapped springform pan in a larger pan, then add hot water halfway up the sides. It keeps the baking even and prevents cracks. Make sure the foil seals tightly—water ruins everything if it gets in! No peeking while it bakes. Once it’s done, let it slowly cool in the oven, door cracked open. The center should jiggle slightly as it’ll firm up while cooling.
- → Can I use store-bought dough?
Totally! Using pre-made sugar cookie dough saves time. Let it soften a bit to press easily into the pan. Breaking it into small pieces first helps it spread better. Some brands are firmer, so pick one that doesn’t get too soft while baking. Smooth it out with damp hands to avoid sticking. For garnish, sprinkle a touch of sugar before baking—it’ll look homemade!
- → How should leftovers be stored?
Keep it chilled! Store in an airtight container in the fridge for up to five days. Wrap individual slices tightly with plastic wrap to prevent drying out. Don’t freeze the whole thing—it messes up the texture. Want to freeze slices? Wrap them well and let them thaw in the fridge overnight. Serve at room temp for that creamy texture, or try it half-frozen—it’s a summer favorite!
Conclusion
Want more ideas? Make mini bites with crumbled cookies, or layer cookies and cream for a no-bake option. Tastes just as amazing, just with a different style!