Pin it
The first time I whipped up Trisha Yearwood's slow cooker mac and cheese for my family get-together, I was hooked. There's something magical about how the cheese transforms into this incredible sauce that hugs every pasta piece. I've completely ditched the boxed stuff since finding this gem. It's now my trusty standby for everything from casual potlucks to big holiday meals or just when we're craving something that feels like a warm blanket.
Effortless Comfort On Your Table
What really gets me about this dish is how your slow cooker handles everything while you're busy with other stuff. You'll get this amazingly smooth sauce that clings to each noodle just right. I've played around with swapping cheeses and trying different toppings, but I always come back to the classic version - it just hits different.
Your Ingredient List
- Cooking spray: A little spritz now saves you tons of scrubbing later.
- 1 pound elbow macaroni: These little curved tubes are perfect sauce catchers.
- 2 cans evaporated milk: This is why your sauce turns out ultra-velvety.
- 2 cups whole milk: Helps everything come together smoothly.
- 1 stick butter: Let's be honest, real butter makes everything better.
- 4 cups sharp cheddar: Grab a block and shred it yourself - you'll taste the difference.
- Salt and pepper: Add to match your preference.
- Paprika: A dash on top gives such a nice pop of color.
Simple Cooking Method
- Get Your Slow Cooker Ready
- First thing, coat your slow cooker with cooking spray so nothing sticks and cleanup's a breeze.
- Throw Everything In
- Put your pasta, both milks, butter, salt and most of your hand-grated cheddar right in the pot. Stir it gently and scatter the leftover cheese on top.
- Set It And Forget It
- Put the lid on and cook on low for 3 hours and 15 minutes. Don't lift the lid - that trapped steam is crucial.
- Dig In
- Give it one last gentle stir to make sure that amazing sauce coats everything, then scoop it out while it's nice and gooey.
Tricks I've Learned
I've made this so many times now and picked up some tricks along the way. Skip those bags of pre-shredded cheese, they just don't melt right. Go easy on the stirring or you'll end up with mushy pasta. I usually sneak a quick look around the 2-hour mark to check how the pasta's doing. And seriously, keep that lid closed during cooking - it's the steam that works the magic.
Tasty Twists
I like to switch things up sometimes with a bit of gouda for smokiness or some velveeta for extra creaminess. My little ones go crazy when I scatter crunchy breadcrumbs over the top. When we want a kick, I'll mix in some diced jalapeños or a few drops of hot sauce. And for those really special meals, swapping heavy cream for milk takes it to a whole new level of rich.
What To Serve With It
At our place, this mac and cheese works with just about anything. We love pairing it with some buttery garlic bread or a fresh green salad. It's amazing next to some BBQ chicken or a pile of juicy pulled pork. Sometimes we don't even bother with a main dish and just serve it with a simple veggie side. No matter what's on the table, everyone always wants another scoop.
Questions You Might Have
People often ask me why their version turned out mushy, and it's usually from cooking it too long or stirring it too much. If yours seems grainy, you probably used bagged shredded cheese or your heat was too high. You can try any pasta shape you like, just watch your timing. And nope, you don't need to boil the pasta first - that's what makes this recipe so great, your slow cooker does all the hard work.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why grate cheese yourself?
Pre-shredded options have anti-clump additives, which can stop it from melting perfectly. Freshly grated cheese ensures smooth, creamy results without lumps.
- → What makes egg yolks special?
Yolks don’t curdle easily, unlike whole eggs, and they bring a rich, custardy feel to your dish. Optional but worth it!
- → How can I tell it’s ready?
Stir and check on the pasta at the 2-hour mark. Time varies per slow cooker size, so aim for tender—not overcooked—pasta. Add time in half-hour increments if needed.
- → Can I make a bigger batch?
For sure! Grab a bigger slow cooker and keep an eye on cooking times. Make adjustments on the go if you’re doubling the recipe.
- → Why mix two milks?
Evaporated milk keeps the sauce rich and prevents splitting, while whole milk ensures the consistency is just right. They’re a perfect pair for creamy results.