Pin it
The whole house gets cozy when this smooth Butternut Squash Mac and Cheese starts cooking in the oven. I've tweaked this dish for years until it hit perfection. Sweet butternut squash pairs wonderfully with nutty Gruyère cheese, creating something truly special with each mouthful. My kids start asking for this the minute autumn arrives, and I totally get why.
Why This Dish Stands Out
This goes way beyond regular mac and cheese. Through lots of kitchen testing, I found that butternut squash creates this amazing velvety consistency that's just incredible. The nutty Gruyère adds depth, and when I mix in some kale, everyone eats their veggies without even realizing it. You'll definitely make this your favorite when you're craving something warm and tasty.
Ingredients You'll Want
- 3 cups cold mashed potatoes: Leftover potatoes that are chilled work great. If you're making fresh ones, let them cool all the way so they're easier to mix.
- 2 large eggs: At room temperature, beaten until they're light and bubbly. They help everything stick together and make the texture fluffy.
- 1/4 cup fresh chives: Cut very small. You can use dried chives instead, but only 1 tablespoon. Green onions work too if that's what you have.
- 1 1/2 cups Monterey Jack cheese: Freshly grated works best (1 cup goes in the mix, 1/2 cup on top). The pre-shredded stuff doesn't melt quite as well.
- 1 teaspoon salt: Fine sea salt or kosher salt to bring out all the flavors.
- 1/2 teaspoon black pepper: Grinding it fresh gives the best taste.
- 1/2 cup sour cream: If you want it for serving. Full-fat kind has the nicest texture.
Follow These Simple Steps
- Preheat and Prepare
- Put your oven rack in the middle and heat to 400°F (200°C). Spray every cup of a 24-cup mini muffin tin with cooking spray, making sure to get the corners too.
- Create the Mixture
- In a big bowl, mix your cold potatoes with the beaten eggs until barely combined. Add 1 cup cheese, your chives, salt, and pepper. Stir gently until everything's mixed, but don't overdo it.
- Fill Muffin Cups
- Take a small cookie scoop or a couple spoons and put about 2 tablespoons of mix in each cup. They should be full but not spilling over. Pat the tops flat with the back of a spoon. Sprinkle the leftover 1/2 cup cheese over all of them.
- Bake to Perfect
- Cook for 15-20 minutes, turning the pan halfway, until they're golden on top with crispy edges. The cheese should be totally melted and a bit browned. Stick a knife in the middle - it should come out clean.
- Cool and Serve
- Take them out and let them sit in the pan for exactly 5 minutes so they can firm up. Carefully run a plastic knife around each one to free it, then put them on a serving plate. Add more chives if you want and serve right away with sour cream on the side.
Insider Tips From My Kitchen
Don't cheap out on the cheese, it really matters. Keep an eye on your pasta, soggy shells are the worst. You can leave the nuts out if needed, pumpkin seeds work great too. Always let it sit a bit before serving so the sauce gets nice and thick.
Customize It Your Way
Add some cooked chicken if you want more protein. Fresh spinach works great for kale haters. Try smoky gouda instead - my children absolutely love that version. Top with crunchy bacon pieces for special times or just pile on extra cheese to keep it basic.
Fast Answers to Your Questions
It tastes like smooth butternut with rich cheese and hints of garlic. You can totally skip the greens or use something else. Leftovers stay good in the freezer for 3 months. If you're vegan, just use your favorite non-dairy cheese and swap in some cashew cream instead of yogurt, it turns out great.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What’s the benefit of using squash in this dish?
It brings a hint of sweetness, a creamy texture, and loads of nutrients, cutting back on the cheese while keeping it tasty.
- → Can I prep this ahead of time?
Absolutely! Freeze it after putting it together (but before baking) or freeze it baked. Bring it to room temp after thawing and reheat.
- → Why pick Greek yogurt?
It boosts protein and adds a tangy flavor while staying creamy. Prefer something else? Cream cheese or sour cream works too.
- → Fresh cheese vs. pre-shredded—why does it matter?
Freshly grated cheese melts like a dream because it skips those anti-clumping additives found in pre-shredded options.
- → Do I have to include kale?
Kale is optional. Skip it or swap for spinach or broccoli for more greens, depending on your taste.