Pin it
Nothing beats homemade baked mac and cheese with its soft noodles and velvety, rich cheese coating that reminds you of childhood dinners. The simple pantry staples and careful oven time create that magical mix of melty insides with a crispy crust that makes this dish so beloved. It's done in roughly 60 minutes, making it great for weeknight family meals or special occasions.
Benefits of This Dish
You'll find only genuine cheese and basic items here - no fake powder mixes or mystery ingredients. The sauce turns out smooth every single time, while the topping gets perfectly crunchy during baking. It won't break your budget since it uses everyday kitchen staples. And you can prep it ahead when you've got a busy schedule or when company's coming over.
Ingredients List
- Pasta: 1 pound small elbow macaroni or similar shaped pasta
- Butter: 1/2 cup unsalted, split between noodles and cheese mixture
- Flour: 1/4 cup to create thickness
- Milk: 3 cups whole milk, slightly heated
- Seasonings: 1 teaspoon each salt and pepper, 1/2 teaspoon paprika
- Hot Sauce: Few drops if you want some kick (optional)
- Cheese: 5 cups grated sharp cheddar, split for sauce and topping
Cooking Instructions
- Prepare the Noodles
- Cook macaroni until slightly soft, around 8 minutes. Drain water and mix with 1 tablespoon butter. Get your oven ready at 375°F.
- Begin the Cheese Base
- Melt your leftover butter in big saucepan. Add flour and stir for 2-3 minutes until slightly golden. Pour warm milk in gradually, constantly stirring for smoothness.
- Add the Cheese
- Mix 4 cups cheese and all seasonings into your base. Stir until everything melts together. Toss in your buttered pasta.
- Finish in the Oven
- Transfer everything to a baking dish. Sprinkle remaining cheese on top. Bake 25-30 minutes until it turns golden and starts bubbling.
Pin it
Standout Features
This dish sticks to what works - authentic cheese, smooth sauce, and that irresistible crusty top. You don't need fancy stuff, just straightforward comfort cooking everyone craves. The sauce stays silky, the pasta doesn't get mushy, and that crunchy cheese topping makes every bite worth savoring.
Tricks for Smooth Sauce
Getting that velvety sauce isn't hard if you know a few tricks. Keep your stove at medium-low so nothing burns. Pour milk in bit by bit while stirring constantly to avoid getting lumps. Skip the pre-shredded bags and grate cheese yourself for better melting. Let your cheese sit out a while before cooking with it. Got a grainy sauce? A little warm milk and gentle mixing usually sorts it out.
Custom Variations
After you've mastered the standard version, play around with some fun tweaks. Try blending cheeses like sharp cheddar with creamy Monterey Jack. Scatter some breadcrumbs across the top for more crunch. Throw in bits of cooked bacon or chopped jalapeños for extra flavor. Want more heat? Add extra hot sauce or swap in some pepper jack. Just keep your pasta-to-sauce ratio the same.
Pairing Suggestions
Dish up this mac and cheese straight from the oven alongside a simple green salad for a main course, or pair it with ham or meatloaf as a side. It fits perfectly at holiday tables, community potlucks, or casual weekend family dinners. Feeding a crowd? The recipe easily doubles - just grab a larger dish and cook it 5-10 minutes longer.
Leftover Management
Store any extra portions in the fridge with a cover for up to 4 days. When warming it up, add a dash of milk and heat it slowly in your microwave or oven. Give it a stir now and then to keep the creamy texture. You'll get better results warming smaller amounts rather than the entire leftover dish at once. The pasta tends to soak up sauce while sitting, so that extra splash of milk brings back its creaminess.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What other cheeses can I use?
Want it super creamy? Gouda's great! Monterey Jack adds a smooth flavor too. For a sharper kick, go for sharp cheddar. Blend different kinds for the best mix. Stick to freshly grated cheese—pre-shredded can mess up the texture. Trust me, it'll melt better!
- → Can I make it gluten-free?
Sure, swap in gluten-free pasta. Rice pasta works, just cook it a little less so it doesn't fall apart. Use a gluten-free flour if you're making a roux. Double-check your cheese—some brands toss in starch. Add a bit more liquid since gluten-free recipes sometimes turn thicker.
- → Is it okay to prep ahead?
Absolutely! Combine everything the day before and chill it in the fridge. Let it warm on the counter for a bit before baking. Plan for extra baking time since it's starting cold. Or, bake one pan now and freeze another. If you're reheating, splash in a little milk to loosen the sauce.
- → Any ways to make it special?
Bacon crumbles on top? Amazing. Buttered breadcrumbs for crunch? Definitely. Jalapeños will give it a spicy zing. Even caramelized onions are great. Whatever extras you choose, add them before popping it into the oven for that irresistible golden top.
- → Best method to reheat it?
For the best results, bake it again with a dash of milk stirred in. Cover it up to keep the topping from burning. Using the microwave? Go low and stir often, adding a splash of milk each time. If you've got time, broil just the top for a good crunch at the end!
Conclusion
If creamy dishes make you happy, consider pairing it with a side like toasted garlic cheese bread. Or, toss together a simple veggie casserole—both will fit the comfort vibe!